Journal·August 15, 2026·Cary Kokkonen
If you can't tie it to a deposit.
Builder marketing has a measurement problem. Half the metrics in a typical campaign report feel like results and aren't. Here's the short list of what actually predicts a deposit, and what to stop paying attention to.
I’ve sat through more campaign post-mortems than I’d like to count. Most of them open with the same slide: a chart of impressions, reach, and engagement, trending up and to the right, delivered by someone proud to be the bearer of good news.
The problem is that impressions don’t buy homes. People do. And the vast majority of the metrics agencies lead with (on the builder side, specifically) have no mechanical relationship to whether a buyer wrote a deposit.
This has become more painful as digital tools have made it easier to measure the wrong things with higher precision. We now have beautifully granular data on things that don’t matter. Meanwhile, the measurements that actually predict sellout, the ones my generation of agency principals used to track by hand on a yellow pad, have fallen out of the standard report.
Vanity metrics that read well in a deck
These are the ones that make a campaign look like it’s working, independent of whether it is:
- Impressions and reach. How many people saw the ad. On a builder’s P&L, this is noise. The campaign could show six million impressions and sell three homes.
- Engagement rate. Likes, saves, comments. These skew toward the already-interested; buyers deep in a search often don’t engage with ads at all.
- Click-through rate. Better than impressions, but still proximate. A high CTR on a campaign that drives traffic to a page that doesn’t convert is a successful cost centre.
- Followers / mailing-list size. Measures audience-building, not deposit-building. A list of 40,000 that converts at 0.3% is less valuable than a list of 2,000 that converts at 11%.
- Site traffic. Same problem: traffic is the top of the funnel; what matters is what shape the funnel has below the traffic metric.
None of these are useless. Impressions matter for brand lift over quarters. CTR matters for ad optimization. The problem is that when they’re the headline of the campaign report, the builder is being told the campaign worked when the campaign may not have.
Metrics that actually predict deposits
The ones I ask every campaign report to include, up front:
- Registration-to-appointment ratio. Of the buyers who registered interest, what fraction booked a sales-centre appointment? Below 15% and the registration flow is leaking at the follow-up step. Below 8% and the campaign is attracting the wrong buyers.
- Appointment-to-deposit ratio. Of the buyers who sat down with a rep, what fraction wrote a deposit? Below 20% and either the sales-centre choreography has a problem or the campaign over-promised something the product can’t deliver. Over 45% and either your pricing is below the market or the rep is doing something exceptional and worth studying.
- Days-to-sellout by launch tier. VIP phase, broker phase, public phase. How many days did each tier take? If VIP sold out in two hours and the public phase took six months, your campaign bought a dramatic launch day and then stopped converting. If VIP took three weeks, the VIP list was too thin going in.
- Cost per deposit. Total campaign spend divided by homes deposited on. This is the actual answer to “did the campaign work?” Report it monthly. Report it per tier. Report it compared to the previous launch.
- Repeat deposit rate. Of buyers who deposited at your community, how many came from a previous community you built? High repeat rate is a brand health indicator that nothing else captures. One builder we work with runs around 18–22% on this at new launches; the industry average is somewhere closer to 7%.
These are the measurements the sales-centre reps can tell you about from memory. They’re the measurements that correlate with whether the campaign actually did its job. They’re boring compared to a reach chart, and they’re the only ones that matter.
The digital-vs-print question, briefly
I’m asked at least twice a quarter whether print still works in builder marketing. The honest answer is: for the right buyer, yes, far more than people on the agency side want to admit. Older move-up buyers, luxury buyers over sixty, buyers in rural markets with slower digital adoption: print is still often the most efficient channel per deposit for these segments. On the other hand: first-time buyers, buyers under thirty-five, buyers in dense urban markets: digital, overwhelmingly.
The question isn’t whether print works. The question is whether it works per deposit for your specific buyer. If a print spend of $38,000 drives six deposits on a community averaging $740,000 and a digital spend of $110,000 drives nine deposits, print just outperformed. If the ratios flip for the next community, use digital. The channel isn’t the point. The deposit per dollar is the point.
What to ask the agency
Three questions, every quarter:
- “What’s our cost per deposit on this campaign?” If the agency can’t answer, the agency isn’t tracking the thing the campaign exists for.
- “What’s leaking most in the registration → appointment → deposit funnel?” If the answer is “we’re not sure,” push harder. This is where campaigns go to die quietly.
- “What did we spend money on in the last 90 days that we can’t tie to a deposit?” The honest answer should be around 15–25% of the campaign. Brand-building investments that don’t convert in-period are legitimate. If it’s over 40%, the campaign is marketing for its own sake, not for the launch.
If you can’t tie the metric to a deposit, you can’t tie the campaign to a result.
The principle: If you can’t tie the metric to a deposit, you can’t tie the campaign to a result.
Filed under
metrics · builder marketing · launch strategy